Most OECD countries spend substantially more on maternity leave schemes than on early childcare. However, given high tax burdens and rapidly aging populations, female labor force participation is critically needed. Moreover, it is important to know whether the main beneficiaries, the children themselves, reap more benefits from one or the other in the long term. The first cohorts exposed to the introduction or extension of maternity/paternity leave schemes and subsidized childcare programs have now completed education and entered the labor market, allowing an investigation of these programs' long-term economic effects.
Maternity leave versus early childcare—What are the long-term consequences for children?
Despite increasingly generous parental leave schemes their advantages over subsidized childcare remain unclear
Nabanita Datta GUPTA
Aarhus University and IZA
- Expansions of universal formal childcare generate positive long-term effects on child outcomes.
- Effects seem to be strongest for cognitive outcomes, in particular language skills.
- Children from low socio-economic backgrounds seem to benefit most, while those from high socio-economic backgrounds do not gain as much but are not hurt either.
- High-quality childcare, which brings together children from diverse backgrounds at an early age, enhances intergenerational mobility.
- Extensions of maternity leave beyond the first few months generate few positive long-term effects on child outcomes, especially when the alternative care quality is high.
- Not all childcare expansions are successful; they need to be of high quality and have widespread societal support.
- Children's non-cognitive outcomes suffer when childcare is of poor quality or if weekly hours spent in care are high.
- Not all children benefit equally from childcare, and varying effects have been found by gender and family income.
Author's main message
Governments should subsidize universal formal childcare, both to meet labor demands in aging societies, and to help develop important skills during the critical early years of a child's life. Such investments generate substantial long-term returns in educational and employment outcomes, but are most apparent for children from low and middle socio-economic backgrounds. However, care must be taken to counter any deterioration in non-cognitive skills associated with increased time in childcare, and broad-based societal acceptance and support are necessary to ensure that childcare provision is of sufficiently high quality.
This article first appeared on IZA World of Labor in May 2018. Reproduced with permission
October 12, 2018